{"query":{"text":"art","properties":{"aspectSpace":"query=art&mode=all","aspectSpacePolygon":"0,0 0.5,0 0.5,0.5 0,0.5","format":"json"},"start":"2026-04-11T15:15:59.072837Z"},"arguments":[{"id":"Se13b1d03-Acf23c508","conclusion":"Digital art is a lesser form of art then traditional art","premises":[{"text":"Traditional art is expensive My opponent's first point is that traditional art is expensive while digital art is more cost efficient, therefore the two form are equal. However, something being less expensive does not make it better when speaking of quality. Therefore this argument should have no bearing on the resolution. Traditional art is limiting My opponent's next claim is that because it is easier to fix screw ups with digital art then it is for traditional art, the two forms are equal. This point might be useful if the resolution was that it is easier to make digital art. But the easier it is to produce something, the lower the quality will be. The quality of something which took me a minute to make will of course be less then the quality of something that was worked on painstakingly for months. Just because it is hard to make a piece of traditional art does not mean that digital art is on par with it. Traditional art being hard to make just forces the artist to become more skillful and careful in producing the art. Digital art is cheap This point is just a reitterating of my opponent's first point that traditional art is expensive to create. I will negate this contention like I did the first. We are debating on whether or not digital art is a lesser form of traditional art. Price should not come into the question of quality. Digital art can emulate traditional technique. My opponent's next claim is that digital art can be made to look like traditional art. This does not being on par as far as quality goes, just like a counterfeit dollar bill is not worth the same as a real dollar bill. Digital art is difficult to master My opponent now claims that digital art is difficult to create. However this contradicts one of his points in which he states that traditional art is too limiting in that it is harder to fix mistakes made when creating a traditional art work. Either it is easier or more difficult to create digital art. My opponent cannot keep both positions.","stance":"PRO","annotations":[{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":12,"end":15,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":75,"end":78,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":106,"end":109,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":258,"end":323,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Summary","start":258,"end":323,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":324,"end":479,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":336,"end":339,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":436,"end":439,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":467,"end":470,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":580,"end":583,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":868,"end":871,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":899,"end":902,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":934,"end":937,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1033,"end":1036,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1046,"end":1049,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1139,"end":1142,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1261,"end":1264,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1297,"end":1300,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1362,"end":1365,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1442,"end":1445,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1483,"end":1486,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1628,"end":1631,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1691,"end":1694,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1798,"end":1801,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1888,"end":1891,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1954,"end":1957,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"}]}],"context":{"corpora":["args-me-2020-04-01"],"topic":"Digital art is a lesser form of art then traditional art","mode":"discussion","sourceDomain":"debate.org","sourceId":"Se13b1d03","sourceTextConclusionStart":1684,"sourceTextConclusionEnd":1740,"sourceTextPremiseStart":9239,"sourceTextPremiseEnd":11238,"sourceTitle":"Debate: Digital art is a lesser form of art then traditional art | Debate.org","sourceUrl":"https://www.debate.org/debates/Digital-art-is-a-lesser-form-of-art-then-traditional-art/1/","aspectSpaceCartesianX":0.0,"aspectSpaceCartesianY":0.0,"aspectSpaceBarycentricCoordinates":[{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1}],"aspectSpace":"query=art&mode=all"},"summary":"Therefore this argument should have no bearing on the...","explanation":{"score":24.712242245674133,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":15.366961598396301,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":4.672640323638916,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":4.672640149963797,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.5,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.4702435731887817,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":9.460975646972656,"name":"premises:art","details":[{"score":9.460975296298557,"name":"product","details":[{"score":4.575685977935791,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":2.0676627159118652,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":1.233345627784729,"name":"sourceText:art","details":[{"score":1.2333455980075396,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.20000000298023224,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":2.852632999420166,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":2.16176700592041,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},{"score":9.345280647277832,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":9.345280299927595,"name":"product","details":[{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.4702435731887817,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},"stance":"PRO"},{"id":"Se13b1d03-A2d65b66e","conclusion":"Digital art is a lesser form of art then traditional art","premises":[{"text":"Rules: 1. No semantics 2. Both sides have a burden to prove their side 3. All arguments must be organized with postmarks prior to argumentation. (i.e. no huge chunks of text that are all over the place) 4. No semantics or arguing over definitions 5. The moment a rule is broken, the violator will lose the debate. 6. Forfeiting a round does NOT mean that person looses, but if some-one does forfeit a round they will lose a conduct point. Round 1 is for greeting/definitions Rounds 2 and 3 are for argumentation Round 4 is for closing statements and voting issues (No new arguments here.) Definitions- 1. Digital art: Art made by digital means, or enhanced through a digital platfom (Pixel art, digital paintings, edited photography etc.) 2. Traditional art: Art made with-out any kind of digital medium. (Painting, colored pencils, copic marker art, etc.)","stance":"CON","annotations":[{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":317,"end":438,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Summary","start":317,"end":438,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":605,"end":702,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":613,"end":616,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":618,"end":621,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":690,"end":693,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":754,"end":757,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":759,"end":762,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":846,"end":849,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"}]}],"context":{"corpora":["args-me-2020-04-01"],"topic":"Digital art is a lesser form of art then traditional art","mode":"discussion","sourceDomain":"debate.org","sourceId":"Se13b1d03","sourceTextConclusionStart":1684,"sourceTextConclusionEnd":1740,"sourceTextPremiseStart":2158,"sourceTextPremiseEnd":3015,"sourceTitle":"Debate: Digital art is a lesser form of art then traditional art | Debate.org","sourceUrl":"https://www.debate.org/debates/Digital-art-is-a-lesser-form-of-art-then-traditional-art/1/","aspectSpaceCartesianX":0.0,"aspectSpaceCartesianY":0.0,"aspectSpaceBarycentricCoordinates":[{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1}],"aspectSpace":"query=art&mode=all"},"summary":"Forfeiting a round does NOT mean that person looses, but...","explanation":{"score":24.10623562335968,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":14.760954976081848,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":4.672640323638916,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":4.672640149963797,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.5,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.4702435731887817,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":8.854969024658203,"name":"premises:art","details":[{"score":8.854968850890828,"name":"product","details":[{"score":4.575685977935791,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.9352221488952637,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":1.233345627784729,"name":"sourceText:art","details":[{"score":1.2333455980075396,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.20000000298023224,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":2.852632999420166,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":2.16176700592041,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},{"score":9.345280647277832,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":9.345280299927595,"name":"product","details":[{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.4702435731887817,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},"stance":"CON"},{"id":"S970b3834-Aaad757da","conclusion":"Graffiti is art","premises":[{"text":"Thanks for accepting. Now for rebuttals: 1. \"I think that if you want to do art, you should do it so it looks nice.\" Art does not have to \"look nice\". Art can be seen in many ways, looks don't matter. If I precisely drew an ugly person to represent that everyone is beautiful no matter what looks, it would still be art wouldn't it? 2. \" Graffiti on walls or doors or trucks or wherever is not art. You are kind of ruining the thing if you draw graffiti. \" Destruction can also be seen as art. Art is very vague, so it is seen in many different ways. Let em elaborate. Take \"The art of war\", a book written by a man of the name Sun Tzu. War brings destruction, yet there is an art to it. Same for graffiti, though you are ruining a wall, you are skilfully creating art, under the pressure of being caught. There is an art in that! 3. \"Graffiti is usually letters put together.\" No way! Graffiti is usually pictures, images, and sometimes letters. And if you didn't know, when you put letters together, it is called a \"word\". Say it with me now, \"word\". And even if it is mostly words, writing is an art. They are sharing codes, words, on a wall. There is an art to that. They are painting their stories onto a wall. 4. \" I'm trying to say that art is something that makes you feel good inside. \" Well as I said earlier, war is an art. Does war make you feel good inside? Art does not need to make you feel good? Also there are horror movies, that scare people. It is an art of creating movies. But do these movies make you feel good and happy and safe inside? 5. \"Art, on the other hand, makes you feel like you should admire the work and stay. \" Some art is boring, or to tedious to understand. But it is still art. Now that I rendered all my opponent's points invalid, I would like to continue with my arguments. Before we can even begin to explain how graffiti is art, we need to understand definitions. Graffiti: \"writing or drawings scribbled, scratched, or sprayed illicitly on a wall or other surface in a public place:\" [1] Art: \" the expression or application of human creative skill and imagination, typically in a visual form such as painting or sculpture, producing works to be appreciated primarily for their beauty or emotional power\" [2] So art is expression, application, creativity! And what do street artist do? (other word for graffiti artist). They apply their skills, expression and creativity onto a huge illegal canvas. This is still art, but just not as respected. Also, it is called graffiti art for a reason. Art is literally in the name! So basically, I just want to explain how anything can be art, graffiti included. Though some art is more respected than others, it doesn't mean the others are not art. Graffiti is an art, involving skill, and knowledge. \"Where can I put graffiti without getting caught? What message of logo or picture do I wan't to express?\" These are questions that echo through the minds of graffiti artist. They create art that is not accepted, but it is still art. Art that is hard to create, but still as amazing as the ones that society accepts. 1.http://www.oxforddictionaries.com... 2.http://www.oxforddictionaries.com... Back to you con!","stance":"PRO","annotations":[{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":76,"end":79,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":117,"end":120,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":151,"end":154,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":316,"end":319,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":394,"end":397,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":489,"end":492,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":494,"end":497,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":579,"end":582,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":677,"end":680,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":765,"end":768,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":818,"end":821,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":886,"end":946,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1099,"end":1102,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1158,"end":1161,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1244,"end":1247,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1330,"end":1333,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1371,"end":1374,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1470,"end":1473,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1564,"end":1567,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1652,"end":1655,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1712,"end":1715,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1867,"end":1870,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":2032,"end":2035,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":2256,"end":2259,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":2457,"end":2460,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":2517,"end":2520,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":2535,"end":2538,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":2622,"end":2625,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":2658,"end":2661,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":2728,"end":2731,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":2748,"end":2751,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":2971,"end":2974,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":3013,"end":3016,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":3018,"end":3021,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":3101,"end":3195,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Summary","start":3101,"end":3195,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"}]}],"context":{"corpora":["args-me-2020-04-01"],"topic":"Graffiti is art","mode":"discussion","sourceDomain":"debate.org","sourceId":"S970b3834","sourceTextConclusionStart":1631,"sourceTextConclusionEnd":1646,"sourceTextPremiseStart":3976,"sourceTextPremiseEnd":7172,"sourceTitle":"Debate: Graffiti is art | Debate.org","sourceUrl":"https://www.debate.org/debates/Graffiti-is-art/4/","aspectSpaceCartesianX":0.0,"aspectSpaceCartesianY":0.0,"aspectSpaceBarycentricCoordinates":[{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1}],"aspectSpace":"query=art&mode=all"},"summary":"Graffiti is usually pictures, images, and sometimes...","explanation":{"score":22.76824915409088,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":14.676038384437561,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":4.04610538482666,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":4.046105455404984,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.5,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.2731047868728638,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":9.388359069824219,"name":"premises:art","details":[{"score":9.388358728344656,"name":"product","details":[{"score":4.575685977935791,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":2.051792621612549,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":1.2415739297866821,"name":"sourceText:art","details":[{"score":1.2415739704847033,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.20000000298023224,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":2.852632999420166,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":2.176189422607422,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},{"score":8.09221076965332,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":8.092210910809968,"name":"product","details":[{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.2731047868728638,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},"stance":"PRO"},{"id":"S68a6a348-A40c98f09","conclusion":"Modern Art","premises":[{"text":"I am an artist, and I can understand modern art. I do believe firmly that the \"lines and colours\" hold certain, deep, and unforgettable memories or thoughts for the artist, but modern art is being taken too far. Art is for viewing, and in the case of modern art, there is nothing there to visualize, to compare to. Picasso's work's are generally considered the first of modern art, and in his art, you can clearly see a scene, but also follow is train of thought throughout the piece, as if a surreal dream, in the context of modern art that you have been describing, there is no basis for the viewer, and therefore, there is no connection to be made, between the art and the viewer. Conclusion: My points are clear, and ideals driven, I deeply love \"modern art\" and hate it at the exact same time. In any sense, what are you hoping to accomplish with the title of this debate being \"Modern Art\"? Is this debate, a manifestation of art too?","stance":"CON","annotations":[{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":44,"end":47,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":49,"end":211,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":184,"end":187,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":212,"end":215,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":258,"end":261,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Summary","start":315,"end":683,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":315,"end":376,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":377,"end":380,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":393,"end":396,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":533,"end":536,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":664,"end":667,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":758,"end":761,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":891,"end":894,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":932,"end":935,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"}]}],"context":{"corpora":["args-me-2020-04-01"],"topic":"Modern Art","mode":"discussion","sourceDomain":"debate.org","sourceId":"S68a6a348","sourceTextConclusionStart":1624,"sourceTextConclusionEnd":1634,"sourceTextPremiseStart":2523,"sourceTextPremiseEnd":3464,"sourceTitle":"Online Debate: Modern Art | Debate.org","sourceUrl":"https://www.debate.org/debates/Modern-Art/2/","aspectSpaceCartesianX":0.0,"aspectSpaceCartesianY":0.0,"aspectSpaceBarycentricCoordinates":[{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1}],"aspectSpace":"query=art&mode=all"},"summary":"I do believe firmly that the \"lines and colours\" hold...","explanation":{"score":22.7285817861557,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":14.63637101650238,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":4.04610538482666,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":4.046105455404984,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.5,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.2731047868728638,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":9.367424964904785,"name":"premises:art","details":[{"score":9.36742490041263,"name":"product","details":[{"score":4.575685977935791,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":2.047217607498169,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":1.222840666770935,"name":"sourceText:art","details":[{"score":1.2228407254679243,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.20000000298023224,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":2.852632999420166,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":2.1433544158935547,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},{"score":8.09221076965332,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":8.092210910809968,"name":"product","details":[{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.2731047868728638,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},"stance":"CON"},{"id":"S68a6a329-A4fe5f66","conclusion":"Modern Art","premises":[{"text":"Definitions Because Pro does not provide definitions, I will provide universal definitions. Art-the expression or application of human creative skill and imagination, typically in a visual form such as painting or sculpture, producing works to be appreciated primarily for their beauty or emotional power. Modern art is the same but during the period from the 1860s to present. Attacks The drawings the Pro give us are also modernabstractart. http://www.newsweek.com... These are also modern art. Modern Art can include structures and 3-D art as well. Gillian Wearing and Marjetica Potrc are famous modern artists. Also, its like a song. Art contains a hidden meaning like some songs do. Another great part about modern art are the ways you can interpret them. Just because you can't feel them doesn't mean they are pointless. Video games are art, but no type of art can be the real art. Art is expressing yourself in your own creative way. Thank you!","stance":"PRO","annotations":[{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":92,"end":305,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":92,"end":95,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":313,"end":316,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":492,"end":495,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":504,"end":507,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":539,"end":542,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Summary","start":638,"end":687,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":638,"end":650,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":638,"end":641,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":720,"end":723,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":843,"end":846,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":863,"end":866,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":883,"end":886,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":888,"end":891,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"}]}],"context":{"corpora":["args-me-2020-04-01"],"topic":"Modern Art","mode":"discussion","sourceDomain":"debate.org","sourceId":"S68a6a329","sourceTextConclusionStart":1632,"sourceTextConclusionEnd":1642,"sourceTextPremiseStart":2720,"sourceTextPremiseEnd":3672,"sourceTitle":"Online Debate: Modern Art | Debate.org","sourceUrl":"https://www.debate.org/debates/Modern-Art/1/","aspectSpaceCartesianX":0.0,"aspectSpaceCartesianY":0.0,"aspectSpaceBarycentricCoordinates":[{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1}],"aspectSpace":"query=art&mode=all"},"summary":"Art-the expression or application of human creative skill...","explanation":{"score":22.544997572898865,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":14.452786803245544,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":4.04610538482666,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":4.046105455404984,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.5,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.2731047868728638,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":9.189247131347656,"name":"premises:art","details":[{"score":9.18924681324529,"name":"product","details":[{"score":4.575685977935791,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":2.008277416229248,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":1.217434287071228,"name":"sourceText:art","details":[{"score":1.2174343098678886,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.20000000298023224,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":2.852632999420166,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":2.133878231048584,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},{"score":8.09221076965332,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":8.092210910809968,"name":"product","details":[{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.2731047868728638,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},"stance":"PRO"},{"id":"S970b37d7-Ab55733e","conclusion":"Graffiti is art","premises":[{"text":"On dictionary.com, vandalism is described as willful or ignorant destruction of artistic or literary treasures. So once again vandalism and graffiti are destruction of art not production of art. \"Ergo, graffiti is a hated, misjudged form of art.\" -It is hated because it destroys art, otherwise aren't we supposed to look at art fondly? If graffiti is photoshop it is the 'erase button' and thus is not art. Even if it was function of photo shop it cannot be art itself so this photoshop option is very out of place. In round 3 your analogy of old and new artists is very unuseful and is off-topic. Being afraid and whether graffiti is art are not at all related and only put confusion to your conclusion. And to correct your last sentence in round 3- So in conclusion, graffiti is a form of spontaneous dangerous crime that is only excepted by few who are in the same criminal profession.","stance":"CON","annotations":[{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":0,"end":175,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.StartOfPremiseSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":168,"end":171,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":190,"end":193,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":241,"end":244,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":280,"end":283,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":325,"end":328,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":403,"end":406,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":459,"end":462,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":636,"end":639,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"}]}],"context":{"corpora":["args-me-2020-04-01"],"topic":"Graffiti is art","mode":"discussion","sourceDomain":"debate.org","sourceId":"S970b37d7","sourceTextConclusionStart":1632,"sourceTextConclusionEnd":1647,"sourceTextPremiseStart":8321,"sourceTextPremiseEnd":9211,"sourceTitle":"Debate: Graffiti is art | Debate.org","sourceUrl":"https://www.debate.org/debates/Graffiti-is-art/1/","aspectSpaceCartesianX":0.0,"aspectSpaceCartesianY":0.0,"aspectSpaceBarycentricCoordinates":[{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1}],"aspectSpace":"query=art&mode=all"},"summary":"On dictionary.com, vandalism is described as willful or...","explanation":{"score":22.503236293792725,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":14.411025524139404,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":4.04610538482666,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":4.046105455404984,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.5,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.2731047868728638,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":9.12966537475586,"name":"premises:art","details":[{"score":9.12966575052667,"name":"product","details":[{"score":4.575685977935791,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.9952561855316162,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":1.2352547645568848,"name":"sourceText:art","details":[{"score":1.2352548328830515,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.20000000298023224,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":2.852632999420166,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":2.1651134490966797,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},{"score":8.09221076965332,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":8.092210910809968,"name":"product","details":[{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.2731047868728638,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},"stance":"CON"},{"id":"S68a6a329-A22342a39","conclusion":"Modern Art","premises":[{"text":"Once again, I never said that having a message makes it necessarily good. http://painting.about.com... This is evidence on how to judge ppaintings. http://www.urbandictionary.com... These \"line drawings\" are abstract art. This type of art has its own purpose in the different ways of art. Buyers of art chose this art because they think it means something very important to them. I repeat myself, I never said that songs aren't only judged by their message, and I never said that messages aren't the only other thing, but to the art you point at, abstract art, these are special because of there unique differential views. You constantly drop the arguement that the art is absract. So, you are making flawed conclusions to these drawings. I state once more that art can be seen to everyone differently. So, just becasue you see it bad, it doesn't mean that the art is now pointless. I have attacked the Pro's weak case with evidence.","stance":"PRO","annotations":[{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":217,"end":220,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":235,"end":238,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":284,"end":287,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":289,"end":379,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":299,"end":302,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":314,"end":317,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Summary","start":380,"end":622,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":380,"end":510,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":529,"end":532,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":556,"end":559,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":666,"end":669,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":762,"end":765,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":861,"end":864,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"}]}],"context":{"corpora":["args-me-2020-04-01"],"topic":"Modern Art","mode":"discussion","sourceDomain":"debate.org","sourceId":"S68a6a329","sourceTextConclusionStart":1632,"sourceTextConclusionEnd":1642,"sourceTextPremiseStart":4646,"sourceTextPremiseEnd":5580,"sourceTitle":"Online Debate: Modern Art | Debate.org","sourceUrl":"https://www.debate.org/debates/Modern-Art/1/","aspectSpaceCartesianX":0.0,"aspectSpaceCartesianY":0.0,"aspectSpaceBarycentricCoordinates":[{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1}],"aspectSpace":"query=art&mode=all"},"summary":"Buyers of art chose this art because they think it means...","explanation":{"score":22.465607047080994,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":14.373396277427673,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":4.04610538482666,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":4.046105455404984,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.5,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.2731047868728638,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":9.109856605529785,"name":"premises:art","details":[{"score":9.109856669928945,"name":"product","details":[{"score":4.575685977935791,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.99092698097229,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":1.217434287071228,"name":"sourceText:art","details":[{"score":1.2174343098678886,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.20000000298023224,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":2.852632999420166,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":2.133878231048584,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},{"score":8.09221076965332,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":8.092210910809968,"name":"product","details":[{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.2731047868728638,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},"stance":"PRO"},{"id":"S970b3834-A665489d8","conclusion":"Graffiti is art","premises":[{"text":"This debate is quite exciting. I apologize for the amount of time it took me to respond. Rebuttals: \"I. It is humiliation because its their property, and its their opinion on how they want the place to look. If they want it to look \"artistic\" they would do it or have someone do it. But they dont want \"art\" on their property. Therefore, it is humiliation.\" First of all, graffiti is not only on walls, or other peoples property, but also on paper. Because of such, according to the definition we have established, graffiti is a form of art. To continue, though it may be \"humiliating\" it is still art. Graffiti is illegal, and some people think it is wrong, or humiliating, but how does this take away what it is? Art is seen in everything, including graffiti. Just because it may be seen as humiliating, it is still an art. Anyway. some people do not think graffiti is humiliation, including me. So not in all cases graffiti is humiliation, but it is art in all cases, no matter how you see it. \"II. Ok if you ask me, I think that ruining from neighborhoods to blocks, to every single property they dont own is worse than killing thousands and saving millions to make the world a better place.\" How on earth does killing thousands of people, destroying millions of cities, and ruining families better than having a few marks in a city that can easily be removed? Tell me how? This is obviously incorrect, even though it is your opinions, it is a terrible one. War is much worst than graffiti. \"In your opinion, destruction is art. But in the opinion who has \"art\" on their property, its destruction. They DONT want art on their property. Therefore, it is not art, its destructing someone's land.\" Though they might not see it art, it is art. It is not my opinion, but the opinion of art itself. Anything is art, and graffiti is one to. Why do you think it's called \"graffiti art\"? It literally has the word art in it! \"V. You can consider it art, but some people wont consider it art. Like I said before, they would consider it... a not-good thing.\" But this is their incorrect opinions. According to our definition, graffiti is art. You can consider it otherwise, but in the end it will always be art. It's like how people think war is a good thing, but no matter what it will always be killing, and destroying. \"Going against the law is not something good.\" Going against the law can be good. It all depends on how you understand the world. If a law is terrible, it is good to go against it. \" If you really want to be so artistic, just do graffiti on a canvas or your own property. \" People do do graffiti on a canvas. And people do it in public for everyone to see, a place where their art has to be seen, you can't ignore it very easily. Arguments: Art is as we have already discussed, any way to express yourself creatively. Graffiti requires such, therefore an art. Graffiti requires expression as I have already mentioned. Here is a text I found in order to elaborate, \"Graffiti is a form of expression, and artists should be free to make their thoughts and beliefs public. Serving as a way to avoid violence, graffiti is an outlet for many to express their feelings. Making street art illegal limits the freedom of artists to create influential masterpieces. Graffiti artists create works that reflect both struggles and accomplishments and at many times display political and social messages. The paint that coats walls in communities everywhere can contain symbolism so profound that it has been compared to poetry.\" [1] As you can see, graffiti requires enough to be seen as an art. Everything can be an art. Even doing nothing is an art. So graffiti is art, no matter how bad, humiliating, or illegal it may be. Graffiti requires creativity, courage, expression, all the signs of a masterpiece. So how could this thing, though illegal possibly not be and art? According to our definition, and all definitions, graffiti is an art, no matter how wrong it may or may not be. sources: 1.http://chscourier.com...","stance":"PRO","annotations":[{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":303,"end":306,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":537,"end":540,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":598,"end":601,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":715,"end":718,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":821,"end":824,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":953,"end":956,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":1462,"end":1494,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1528,"end":1531,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1561,"end":1564,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1617,"end":1620,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1661,"end":1664,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1728,"end":1731,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1739,"end":1742,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1785,"end":1788,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1809,"end":1812,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1877,"end":1880,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1909,"end":1912,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1944,"end":1947,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1982,"end":1985,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":2131,"end":2134,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":2200,"end":2203,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":2692,"end":2695,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":2756,"end":2759,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":2870,"end":2873,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":3192,"end":3195,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":3592,"end":3595,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":3618,"end":3621,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":3648,"end":3651,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":3668,"end":3671,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":3870,"end":3873,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":3940,"end":3943,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":3987,"end":4022,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Summary","start":3987,"end":4022,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"}]}],"context":{"corpora":["args-me-2020-04-01"],"topic":"Graffiti is art","mode":"discussion","sourceDomain":"debate.org","sourceId":"S970b3834","sourceTextConclusionStart":1631,"sourceTextConclusionEnd":1646,"sourceTextPremiseStart":13343,"sourceTextPremiseEnd":17366,"sourceTitle":"Debate: Graffiti is art | Debate.org","sourceUrl":"https://www.debate.org/debates/Graffiti-is-art/4/","aspectSpaceCartesianX":0.0,"aspectSpaceCartesianY":0.0,"aspectSpaceBarycentricCoordinates":[{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1}],"aspectSpace":"query=art&mode=all"},"summary":"War is much worst than graffiti. ... sources:...","explanation":{"score":22.448675751686096,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":14.356464982032776,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":4.04610538482666,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":4.046105455404984,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.5,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.2731047868728638,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":9.068785667419434,"name":"premises:art","details":[{"score":9.068785937370137,"name":"product","details":[{"score":4.575685977935791,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.981951117515564,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":1.2415739297866821,"name":"sourceText:art","details":[{"score":1.2415739704847033,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.20000000298023224,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":2.852632999420166,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":2.176189422607422,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},{"score":8.09221076965332,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":8.092210910809968,"name":"product","details":[{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.2731047868728638,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},"stance":"PRO"},{"id":"S7afaaaed-Aa95c9844","conclusion":"Art that has no discernible point--Modern or Postmodern--is not art","premises":[{"text":"My opponent declares that art must pass certain standards in order to be categorized as art. I have a difficult time following his line of thought, as I have always envisioned art to be an extremely broad term. Going by my opponent's argument, we cannot logically conclude that those things are not art. We can only conclude that these pieces stray from the traditions of past artists and that my opponent dislikes them. I argue that it is impossible to give an objective scale to measure whether something is art or not, so my opponent's declaration that \"X is not art\" is false. Simply put, everything is art.","stance":"CON","annotations":[{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":26,"end":29,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":88,"end":91,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":93,"end":210,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":176,"end":179,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":299,"end":302,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Summary","start":304,"end":420,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":304,"end":405,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":510,"end":513,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":566,"end":569,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":607,"end":610,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"}]}],"context":{"corpora":["args-me-2020-04-01"],"topic":"Art that has no discernible point--Modern or Postmodern--is not art","mode":"discussion","sourceDomain":"debate.org","sourceId":"S7afaaaed","sourceTextConclusionStart":1686,"sourceTextConclusionEnd":1753,"sourceTextPremiseStart":5628,"sourceTextPremiseEnd":6240,"sourceTitle":"Online Debate: Art that has no discernible point--Modern or Postmodern--is not art | Debate.org","sourceUrl":"https://www.debate.org/debates/Art-that-has-no-discernible-point-Modern-or-Postmodern-is-not-art/1/","aspectSpaceCartesianX":0.0,"aspectSpaceCartesianY":0.0,"aspectSpaceBarycentricCoordinates":[{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1}],"aspectSpace":"query=art&mode=all"},"summary":"I have a difficult time following his line of thought, as...","explanation":{"score":22.433388113975525,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":14.41756284236908,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":4.007912635803223,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":4.007912571468296,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.5,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.261087417602539,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":9.171957015991211,"name":"premises:art","details":[{"score":9.17195668666784,"name":"product","details":[{"score":4.575685977935791,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":2.0044987201690674,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":1.237693190574646,"name":"sourceText:art","details":[{"score":1.2376932016760431,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.20000000298023224,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":2.852632999420166,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":2.1693873405456543,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},{"score":8.015825271606445,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":8.015825142936592,"name":"product","details":[{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.261087417602539,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},"stance":"CON"},{"id":"S5173c0e9-A4b8cfba6","conclusion":"Are Videogames Art","premises":[{"text":"art: \"the quality, production, expression, or realm, according to aesthetic principles, of what is beautiful, appealing, or of more than ordinary significance.\" http://dictionary.reference.com... using the word production in the definition of art, means for it to be productive to the soul and those who view the form of art. Thus i will be basing this off productivity. GAMEMAKERS \"but also they are allowed boundless opportunities to use their creativity and imagination, which sounds like art to me.\" video games in themselves are not where the creativity and imagination spark from. the creators of the game being the ones who put forth all the creativity are the ones using imagination and creativity. Such as paintings and soul music can be considered a form of art because of this creativity and imagination that they themselves put into the particular frame of art. but those who view the art, cannot be said to have used the creativity and imagination, simply by viewing the said artwork. so the point here is that the game itself does not spark creativity and imagination, however, but the makers of the game art the ones who have used creativity and imagination. UNPRODUCTIVITY While the people who made them game used a form of art in making the game by being creative and imaginitive, the game in itself does not provide a form of productivity or, seemingly, a specific influential point. For example, everything that is considered art has a certain meaning or phase to the the benefit of learning.meaning Every piece of art must have an influential meaning that can be used as pertaining to human life. Although games like halo and final fantasy did have alot of imagination and creativity used in them and are very fun, they pose no specific point or influential benefits. when and if a game pertained the the inspiration of mankind other than the destruction of it, it could be used as an example of 'a piece of art'. however this is not the case with games such as in all the games you have listed. Dont get me wrong, i enjoy playing video games, and i do think they are fun, but i do not beleieve they would fall uner the category of art. thankyou -philosophical","stance":"CON","annotations":[{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":0,"end":3,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":243,"end":246,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":321,"end":324,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":371,"end":503,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Summary","start":371,"end":503,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":492,"end":495,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":707,"end":798,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":768,"end":771,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":869,"end":872,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":897,"end":900,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1119,"end":1122,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1240,"end":1243,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1445,"end":1448,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1534,"end":1537,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1928,"end":1931,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":2152,"end":2155,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"}]}],"context":{"corpora":["args-me-2020-04-01"],"topic":"Are Videogames Art","mode":"discussion","sourceDomain":"debate.org","sourceId":"S5173c0e9","sourceTextConclusionStart":1648,"sourceTextConclusionEnd":1666,"sourceTextPremiseStart":3694,"sourceTextPremiseEnd":5875,"sourceTitle":"Debate Issue: Are Videogames Art | Debate.org","sourceUrl":"https://www.debate.org/debates/Are-Videogames-Art/1/","aspectSpaceCartesianX":0.0,"aspectSpaceCartesianY":0.0,"aspectSpaceBarycentricCoordinates":[{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1},{"value":0.0,"rank":1}],"aspectSpace":"query=art&mode=all"},"summary":"GAMEMAKERS \"but also they are allowed boundless...","explanation":{"score":22.399694681167603,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":14.307483911514282,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":4.04610538482666,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":4.046105455404984,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.5,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.2731047868728638,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":9.042559623718262,"name":"premises:art","details":[{"score":9.04256001504558,"name":"product","details":[{"score":4.575685977935791,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.9762195348739624,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":1.2188189029693604,"name":"sourceText:art","details":[{"score":1.2188188996226506,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.20000000298023224,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":2.852632999420166,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":2.136305093765259,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},{"score":8.09221076965332,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":8.092210910809968,"name":"product","details":[{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.2731047868728638,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},"stance":"CON"}],"totalSize":540,"resultsBefore":0,"retrievalTimeInMilliseconds":304}