{"query":{"text":"art","properties":{"format":"json","sourceDomain":"idebate,debatepedia"},"start":"2026-04-04T11:03:10.744634Z"},"arguments":[{"id":"S9ef49415-Ac340c878","conclusion":"Just shock-tactics, at the cost of better art","premises":[{"text":"Who determines whether something is too disgusting? It is also hard to separate a piece of work’s artistic merit from its impact. It is perfectly possible for a work of art to display great technical competence, and yet fail to have an emotional impact on its audience, and so as a consequence it seems most sensible to allow, display and fund as wide a display of art as possible. Limiting the forms of art that we display or give funding to those considered ‘artistically meritorious’ will result in the loss of innovation in the art world: if we only encourage those pieces that are ‘good’ under present-day metrics, we lose those pieces of art that, though considered controversial, or ‘not art’ now, may in the future be considered masterpieces (e.g. Picasso’s Guernica). ","stance":"CON","annotations":[{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":130,"end":353,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":169,"end":172,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":365,"end":368,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Summary","start":382,"end":755,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":404,"end":407,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":532,"end":535,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":644,"end":647,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":695,"end":698,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"}]}],"context":{"corpora":["args-me-2020-04-01"],"topic":"THBT social disgust is legitimate grounds for restriction of artistic expression","mode":"discussion","sourceDomain":"idebate","sourceId":"S9ef49415","sourceTextConclusionStart":8996,"sourceTextConclusionEnd":9041,"sourceTextPremiseStart":9851,"sourceTextPremiseEnd":10628,"sourceTitle":"THBT social disgust is legitimate grounds for restriction of artistic expression | idebate.org","sourceUrl":"https://idebate.org/debatabase/culture-arts-human-rights/thbt-social-disgust-legitimate-grounds-restriction-artistic"},"summary":"It is perfectly possible for a work of art to display...","explanation":{"score":18.509035229682922,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":12.89090645313263,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":2.8090643882751465,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":2.809064468952471,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.5,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":0.883870542049408,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":8.854969024658203,"name":"premises:art","details":[{"score":8.854968850890828,"name":"product","details":[{"score":4.575685977935791,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.9352221488952637,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":1.2268730401992798,"name":"sourceText:art","details":[{"score":1.226873025172233,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.20000000298023224,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":2.852632999420166,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":2.1504220962524414,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},{"score":5.618128776550293,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":5.618128937904942,"name":"product","details":[{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":0.883870542049408,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},"stance":"CON"},{"id":"S2ad5d788-Aebfd7f73","conclusion":"Bullfighting is a cultural art form, not a sport","premises":[{"text":"Ernest Hemingway said about bullfighting that it is \"a decadent art in every way [...] if it were permanent it could be one of the major arts.\"[","stance":"PRO","annotations":[{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":0,"end":143,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Summary","start":0,"end":143,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":64,"end":67,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"}]}],"context":{"aspects":[{"name":"Bullfighting","weight":2.0,"normalizedWeight":1.0,"rank":1}],"corpora":["args-me-2020-04-01"],"topic":"Bullfighting","mode":"discussion","sourceDomain":"debatepedia","sourceId":"S2ad5d788","sourceTextConclusionStart":6898,"sourceTextConclusionEnd":6946,"sourceTextPremiseStart":6946,"sourceTextPremiseEnd":7091,"sourceTitle":"Debate: Bullfighting - Debatepedia","sourceUrl":"http://www.debatepedia.org/en/index.php/Debate:_Bullfighting"},"summary":"Ernest Hemingway said about bullfighting that it is \"a...","explanation":{"score":17.960583209991455,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":11.527069091796875,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":3.21675705909729,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":3.216756995985179,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.5,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.012150764465332,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":7.212621212005615,"name":"premises:art","details":[{"score":7.212621193493021,"name":"product","details":[{"score":4.575685977935791,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.576292872428894,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":1.0976908206939697,"name":"sourceText:art","details":[{"score":1.0976908962698575,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.20000000298023224,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":2.852632999420166,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.9239959716796875,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},{"score":6.43351411819458,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":6.433513991970358,"name":"product","details":[{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.012150764465332,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},"stance":"PRO"},{"id":"S9ef49415-A3f62a004","conclusion":"Just shock-tactics, at the cost of better art","premises":[{"text":"Sometimes artists go too far in a bid to get their message across. Simply grabbing the headlines with shock tactics does not constitute art of the sort that should be receiving either public support or attention. It is important to recognise that public displays and funding of art are limited commodities, so every time one piece is chosen for an exhibition, or an artist is given money, this comes at the cost of other possible pieces of art. It is surely better to support those artists who have chosen to express their ideas and messages in a way that does not rely on simple attention-grabbing horror: it is surely more artistically meritorious to create a work that conveys its message in a way that rewards close attention and careful study, with layers of meaning and technique. ","stance":"PRO","annotations":[{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":0,"end":66,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":67,"end":212,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Summary","start":67,"end":212,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":136,"end":139,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":278,"end":281,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":440,"end":443,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"}]}],"context":{"corpora":["args-me-2020-04-01"],"topic":"THBT social disgust is legitimate grounds for restriction of artistic expression","mode":"discussion","sourceDomain":"idebate","sourceId":"S9ef49415","sourceTextConclusionStart":8996,"sourceTextConclusionEnd":9041,"sourceTextPremiseStart":9049,"sourceTextPremiseEnd":9836,"sourceTitle":"THBT social disgust is legitimate grounds for restriction of artistic expression | idebate.org","sourceUrl":"https://idebate.org/debatabase/culture-arts-human-rights/thbt-social-disgust-legitimate-grounds-restriction-artistic"},"summary":"Sometimes artists go too far in a bid to get their...","explanation":{"score":17.55779230594635,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":11.939663529396057,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":2.8090643882751465,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":2.809064468952471,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.5,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":0.883870542049408,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":7.903726100921631,"name":"premises:art","details":[{"score":7.903726065851174,"name":"product","details":[{"score":4.575685977935791,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.7273313999176025,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":1.2268730401992798,"name":"sourceText:art","details":[{"score":1.226873025172233,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.20000000298023224,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":2.852632999420166,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":2.1504220962524414,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},{"score":5.618128776550293,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":5.618128937904942,"name":"product","details":[{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":0.883870542049408,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},"stance":"PRO"},{"id":"S851ff6ca-A92f0ec0e","conclusion":"Poetry is art, art is inseparable from education; art is what makes us human, and that which makes us human is certainly to be taught in schools.","premises":[{"text":"In failing schools, it IS justifiable to separate art from education. When a high number of students are struggling with basic literacy and numeracy, this is what needs to be addressed. Artistic studies will simply have to take a backseat while teaching of the basics is improved. This is a temporary measure, once teaching and abilities in basic literacy and numeracy improve, schools which have previously been failing can expand back into artistic studies. If this is not the case, and art and poetry continue to have a high profile in failing schools, what will result is a mass of very cultured high school leavers (not necessarily graduates) unable to add up in their head and with poor vocabulary, able to quote Shakespeare effortlessly but no idea how to spell his name.","stance":"CON","annotations":[{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":0,"end":69,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":50,"end":53,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Summary","start":460,"end":778,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":460,"end":611,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":489,"end":492,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"}]}],"context":{"corpora":["args-me-2020-04-01"],"topic":"poetry is an unnecessary burden for schools.","mode":"discussion","sourceDomain":"idebate","sourceId":"S851ff6ca","sourceTextConclusionStart":12743,"sourceTextConclusionEnd":12888,"sourceTextPremiseStart":13741,"sourceTextPremiseEnd":14519,"sourceTitle":"This house believes poetry is an unnecessary burden for schools. | idebate.org","sourceUrl":"https://idebate.org/debatabase/culture-arts-education-secondary-teaching-literary-classics/house-believes-poetry"},"summary":"In failing schools, it IS justifiable to separate art...","explanation":{"score":17.55440068244934,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":11.379945993423462,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":3.0872273445129395,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":3.0872274302452922,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.5,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":0.9713943600654602,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":7.137032508850098,"name":"premises:art","details":[{"score":7.137032390706622,"name":"product","details":[{"score":4.575685977935791,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.5597732067108154,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":1.1556861400604248,"name":"sourceText:art","details":[{"score":1.1556861500118991,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.20000000298023224,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":2.852632999420166,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":2.0256481170654297,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},{"score":6.174454689025879,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":6.1744548604905845,"name":"product","details":[{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":0.9713943600654602,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},"stance":"CON"},{"id":"S9ef49415-Ae3d87ee8","conclusion":"We have a duty to protect individuals from the worst reactions to art","premises":[{"text":"Whilst it is the case in individual instances that, if one piece of art is censored, another on a different topic may be produced, when looked at in a wider context this is not the case. If we restrict artists in all cases where someone is disgusted, an enormous quantity of subjects will be off limits. This will have, not only a negative impact on that artist, but a deleterious effect on whole branches of art. Further, restricting any art that could cause social disgust is an unreasonable restriction to place upon society (or gallery curators, or grant allocation committees). It is difficult to know at what point a piece will cross the line from simply ‘provocative’ to ‘disgusting’. Consequently, people will be forced to err on the side of caution, leading to an excessive caution and restriction: overcensorship. When weighed against these harms, it is far from clear that individual disgust can be elevated to this extent! ","stance":"CON","annotations":[{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":0,"end":186,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":68,"end":71,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":409,"end":412,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":439,"end":442,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Summary","start":692,"end":823,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":692,"end":730,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"}]}],"context":{"corpora":["args-me-2020-04-01"],"topic":"THBT social disgust is legitimate grounds for restriction of artistic expression","mode":"discussion","sourceDomain":"idebate","sourceId":"S9ef49415","sourceTextConclusionStart":10636,"sourceTextConclusionEnd":10705,"sourceTextPremiseStart":12029,"sourceTextPremiseEnd":12964,"sourceTitle":"THBT social disgust is legitimate grounds for restriction of artistic expression | idebate.org","sourceUrl":"https://idebate.org/debatabase/culture-arts-human-rights/thbt-social-disgust-legitimate-grounds-restriction-artistic"},"summary":"Whilst it is the case in individual instances that, if...","explanation":{"score":16.09410798549652,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":11.45176875591278,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":2.32116961479187,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":2.321169499813152,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.5,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":0.7303546667098999,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":7.903726100921631,"name":"premises:art","details":[{"score":7.903726065851174,"name":"product","details":[{"score":4.575685977935791,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.7273313999176025,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":1.2268730401992798,"name":"sourceText:art","details":[{"score":1.226873025172233,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.20000000298023224,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":2.852632999420166,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":2.1504220962524414,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},{"score":4.64233922958374,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":4.642338999626304,"name":"product","details":[{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":0.7303546667098999,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},"stance":"CON"},{"id":"S851ff6ca-Ab2deada7","conclusion":"Poetry is art, art is inseparable from education; art is what makes us human, and that which makes us human is certainly to be taught in schools.","premises":[{"text":"It is fundamental that education teaches students about the human condition in order to enable an understanding of humanity. High school students must therefore gain awareness of not only human ideas but also an awareness of how humans choose to express these ideas, which means they must learn about art. One of the ways in which humans choose to express their emotions is through literature, language and speech- poetry. For example, many Victorian poets such as William Wordsworth and Sir Walter Scott, who spent much time in the Lake District, turned to writing nature poetry, such as Wordsworth's famous poem Daffodils, because they wanted to \"see into the life of things\",1 and the best way to both investigate and express this was through nature poetry. 1 Lefebure, Molly, The Illustrated Lake Poets, Windward, 1987, p.","stance":"PRO","annotations":[{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":125,"end":305,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":301,"end":304,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Summary","start":423,"end":760,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":423,"end":464,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"}]}],"context":{"corpora":["args-me-2020-04-01"],"topic":"poetry is an unnecessary burden for schools.","mode":"discussion","sourceDomain":"idebate","sourceId":"S851ff6ca","sourceTextConclusionStart":12743,"sourceTextConclusionEnd":12888,"sourceTextPremiseStart":12896,"sourceTextPremiseEnd":13723,"sourceTitle":"This house believes poetry is an unnecessary burden for schools. | idebate.org","sourceUrl":"https://idebate.org/debatabase/culture-arts-education-secondary-teaching-literary-classics/house-believes-poetry"},"summary":"High school students must therefore gain awareness of not...","explanation":{"score":15.945613145828247,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":9.771158456802368,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":3.0872273445129395,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":3.0872274302452922,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.5,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":0.9713943600654602,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":5.528244972229004,"name":"premises:art","details":[{"score":5.528244968270144,"name":"product","details":[{"score":4.575685977935791,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.2081784009933472,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":1.1556861400604248,"name":"sourceText:art","details":[{"score":1.1556861500118991,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.20000000298023224,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":2.852632999420166,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":2.0256481170654297,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},{"score":6.174454689025879,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":6.1744548604905845,"name":"product","details":[{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":0.9713943600654602,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},"stance":"PRO"},{"id":"Sa4c647b7-Af83b2b0f","conclusion":"Bullfighting is an art-form and an important cultural tradition","premises":[{"text":"Ernest Hemingway said about bullfighting that it is \"a decadent art in every way [...] if it were permanent it could be one of the major arts.\"(9) Bullfighting should thus not be understood as simply a 'bloodsport' with some cultural connotations but rather as an inherently cultural art form. The poet Garcia Lorca said in the 1930s that bullfighting is \"the last serious thing in the modern world\".(10) In many ways the seriousness of watching a life-and-death struggle in the arena is nothing short of poetic and this significance is perceived not only by the audience and the bullfighting community but in the wider culture of the nations which currently permit bullfighting. Robert Elms argued in 2010 that, in nations which do not practice bullfighting, “Our squeamishness means that we prefer death which is mechanical and invisible, while the Spanish understand that it is part of a cycle.[...] It is a public celebration of death (a subject we prefer to hide from in Britain) which, when it is done well, becomes a celebration of life. The man charged with the task of delivering a fine end to this fierce and powerful creature will dance with it along the way, laying his own life on the line to create a swirling symbiosis.\"(10) Hemmingway echoed this, arguing that bullfighting promoted an understanding of violent death: \"The only place where you could see life and death, i. e., violent death now that the wars were over, was in the bull ring and I wanted very much to go to Spain where I could study it. I was trying to learn to write, commencing with the simplest things, and one of the simplest things of all and the most fundamental is violent death.\"(9) This is why Madrid and other places have protected and recognized bullfighting as an art form, not just a sport.(1) The understanding and cultural value in the bullfighting nations stems from their long history of the practice. Bullfighting traces its roots to prehistoric bull worship and sacrifice. The killing of the sacred bull (tauroctony) is the essential central iconic act of Mithras, which was commemorated in the mithraeum wherever Roman soldiers were stationed. The oldest representation of what seems to be a man facing a bull is on the celtiberian tombstone from Clunia and the cave painting \"El toro de hachos\", both found in Spain.(8) The continuity of the modern bullfights with these ancient commemorations is shown by the fact that in Spain, many youth idealize bull fighters for their strength, grace, and wit in outmaneuvering bulls.(10) This is valuable in inspiring and compelling success in future generations. Bullfighting is a genuinely popular and enjoyed cultural art form in many nations: Spanish bullrings are not kept alive by tourists. Rather, despite the economic recession which has hit Spain especially hard, the bullfights are still thriving, its top practitioners are huge stars, and its fan are intensely devoted, because it is still the very soul of this dark and complex country. Bullfighting thrives because its local fans are dedicated, and they are dedicated because they perceive its poetry and value to the culture.(10) Thus bullfighting has a cultural value which trumps misplaced concerns regarding 'animal rights', especially as 'animal rights' are simply a concept created by each culture and defined in different ways. Culturally, it is acceptable in the West to eat meat, and so this is legal even though it causes cows to suffer and die. Similarly, the culture of the bullfighting countries places a value upon the bullfight, thus privileging it above the 'rights' of the animal. To allow the moral qualms of other non-bullfighting cultures to dictate cultural practices in Spain or Mexico would be to privilege these other cultures' values above those of bullfighting nations, and deprive them of part of their uniqueness. As Robert Elms argues, if the bullfight dies out due to the pressure of other cultures' moral qualms, bullfighting nations will become \"more like everywhere else, dominated by gaudy globalism and neutered by the homogenising forces of technology and accepted taste.\"(","stance":"PRO","annotations":[{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":64,"end":67,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":284,"end":287,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":1758,"end":1761,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":2664,"end":2667,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Summary","start":2740,"end":2991,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":2740,"end":2965,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"}]}],"context":{"aspects":[{"name":"Bullfighting","weight":17.0,"normalizedWeight":0.7391304347826086,"rank":1},{"name":"Spain","weight":4.0,"normalizedWeight":0.17391304347826086,"rank":2},{"name":"Mexico","weight":1.0,"normalizedWeight":0.043478260869565216,"rank":3},{"name":"Recession","weight":1.0,"normalizedWeight":0.043478260869565216,"rank":3}],"corpora":["args-me-2020-04-01"],"topic":"all nations should ban bullfighting","mode":"discussion","sourceDomain":"idebate","sourceId":"Sa4c647b7","sourceTextConclusionStart":10694,"sourceTextConclusionEnd":10757,"sourceTextPremiseStart":10765,"sourceTextPremiseEnd":14880,"sourceTitle":"This House believes that all nations should ban bullfighting | idebate.org","sourceUrl":"https://idebate.org/debatabase/environment-animals-sport-sport-general/house-believes-all-nations-should-ban"},"summary":"Rather, despite the economic recession which has hit...","explanation":{"score":15.82244884967804,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":10.204320073127747,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":2.8090643882751465,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":2.809064468952471,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.5,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":0.883870542049408,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":6.30764102935791,"name":"premises:art","details":[{"score":6.307640869978172,"name":"product","details":[{"score":4.575685977935791,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.3785126209259033,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":1.08761465549469,"name":"sourceText:art","details":[{"score":1.0876147038178865,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.20000000298023224,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":2.852632999420166,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.9063347578048706,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},{"score":5.618128776550293,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":5.618128937904942,"name":"product","details":[{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":0.883870542049408,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},"stance":"PRO"},{"id":"S40f19507-Ad99fae44","conclusion":"NCLB tests what is testable; art and music is not testable.","premises":[{"text":"While music, art, culture, and physical education are important, they are not testable. You can only create a standardized test around information that is common and fairly objective. No Child Left Behind does this, focusing on history, math, and reading comprehension. It cannot be blamed for not testing arts and music. These subjects are not testable. Schools should, however, teach them, and not merely focus on teaching to the NCLB test.","stance":"PRO","annotations":[{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":13,"end":16,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":88,"end":183,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":355,"end":442,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Summary","start":355,"end":442,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"}]}],"context":{"corpora":["args-me-2020-04-01"],"topic":"No Child Left Behind Act","mode":"discussion","sourceDomain":"debatepedia","sourceId":"S40f19507","sourceTextConclusionStart":8049,"sourceTextConclusionEnd":8108,"sourceTextPremiseStart":8108,"sourceTextPremiseEnd":8551,"sourceTitle":"Debate: No Child Left Behind Act - Debatepedia","sourceUrl":"http://www.debatepedia.org/en/index.php/Debate:_No_Child_Left_Behind_Act"},"summary":"You can only create a standardized test around...","explanation":{"score":15.453779995441437,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":9.835651218891144,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":2.8090643882751465,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":2.809064468952471,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.5,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":0.883870542049408,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":6.319138526916504,"name":"premises:art","details":[{"score":6.31913871142325,"name":"product","details":[{"score":4.575685977935791,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.3810254335403442,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":0.7074483036994934,"name":"sourceText:art","details":[{"score":0.7074483070060936,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.20000000298023224,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":2.852632999420166,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.2399917840957642,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},{"score":5.618128776550293,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":5.618128937904942,"name":"product","details":[{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":0.883870542049408,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},"stance":"PRO"},{"id":"S50689d14-Afcf31aec","conclusion":"Practicing law is more art than science.","premises":[{"text":"Inside law school. LSAC: \"Law is more an art than a science. The reality lawyers seek in analyzing a case is not always well defined. Legal study, therefore, requires an attentive mind and a tolerance for ambiguity. Because many people believe incorrectly that the study of law involves the memorization of rules in books and principles dictated by learned professors, law schools often attract those people who especially value structure, authority, and order. The study of law does not involve this kind of certainty, however; complex legal questions do not have simple legal solutions.\"","stance":"PRO","annotations":[{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":19,"end":60,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":41,"end":44,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":462,"end":589,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Summary","start":462,"end":589,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"}]}],"context":{"corpora":["args-me-2020-04-01"],"topic":"Law school","mode":"discussion","sourceDomain":"debatepedia","sourceId":"S50689d14","sourceTextConclusionStart":51215,"sourceTextConclusionEnd":51255,"sourceTextPremiseStart":51255,"sourceTextPremiseEnd":51845,"sourceTitle":"Debate: Law school - Debatepedia","sourceUrl":"http://www.debatepedia.org/en/index.php/Debate:_Law_school"},"summary":"LSAC: \"Law is more an art than a science. ... The study...","explanation":{"score":14.81021311879158,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":9.192084342241287,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":2.8090643882751465,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":2.809064468952471,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.5,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":0.883870542049408,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":5.982287883758545,"name":"premises:art","details":[{"score":5.982287794085323,"name":"product","details":[{"score":4.575685977935791,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.3074078559875488,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":0.4007320702075958,"name":"sourceText:art","details":[{"score":0.40073209107518504,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.20000000298023224,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":2.852632999420166,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":0.7023898363113403,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},{"score":5.618128776550293,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":5.618128937904942,"name":"product","details":[{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":0.883870542049408,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},"stance":"PRO"},{"id":"S6390f342-A116996ce","conclusion":"The lack of control over, and profit from, art will serve as a serious disincentive to artistic output","premises":[{"text":"Few artists ever see much profit from their work anyway, many choosing the life of bohemian squalor in order to keep producing art rather than taking up more profitable pursuits. Vincent van Gogh sold almost nothing, but his drive to create never abated. No doubt the true artists will continue to feel the urge to create under this policy, and the loss of a few marginal cases must be weighed against the massive losses to art in general, such as the huge curtailment of exploration of and response to existing works, which are often artistically meritorious in their own right, and also the rendering unavailable of much of the artistic output of the world. ","stance":"CON","annotations":[{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":0,"end":178,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":127,"end":130,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Summary","start":255,"end":659,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.Snippet","start":255,"end":302,"source":"me.args.indexing.assessment.snippets.TextRankSnippetGenerator"},{"type":"me.args.argument.QueryTermHighlight","start":424,"end":427,"source":"me.args.retrieval.retrieval.highlight.SimpleQueryTermHighlighter"}]}],"context":{"corpora":["args-me-2020-04-01"],"topic":"all literature, art, photography, film and music should be released under Creative Commons licenses","mode":"discussion","sourceDomain":"idebate","sourceId":"S6390f342","sourceTextConclusionStart":20816,"sourceTextConclusionEnd":20918,"sourceTextPremiseStart":22296,"sourceTextPremiseEnd":22956,"sourceTitle":"This House believes that all literature, art, photography, film and music should be released under Creative Commons licenses | idebate.org","sourceUrl":"https://idebate.org/debatabase/culture-arts-science-censorship-ip-digital-freedoms-access-knowledge/house-believes-all"},"summary":"Few artists ever see much profit from their work anyway,...","explanation":{"score":13.938998579978943,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":10.421382308006287,"name":"sum","details":[{"score":1.7588081359863281,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":1.7588080869681733,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.5,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":0.5534079670906067,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":7.504706382751465,"name":"premises:art","details":[{"score":7.504706403275748,"name":"product","details":[{"score":4.575685977935791,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":1.6401270627975464,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]},{"score":1.1578677892684937,"name":"sourceText:art","details":[{"score":1.1578678412464627,"name":"product","details":[{"score":0.20000000298023224,"name":"boost","details":[]},{"score":2.852632999420166,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":2.0294721126556396,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},{"score":3.5176162719726562,"name":"conclusion:art","details":[{"score":3.5176161739363465,"name":"product","details":[{"score":6.356280326843262,"name":"idf","details":[]},{"score":0.5534079670906067,"name":"tfNorm","details":[]}]}]}]},"stance":"CON"}],"totalSize":29,"resultsBefore":0,"retrievalTimeInMilliseconds":0}